In this Substack Live, David Pakman speaks with Dan Pfeiffer, co-host of Pod Save America and former Obama adviser, about the Democratic Party’s messaging struggles and what it will take to compete in the current media environment. Both note that while Democrats have started appearing on podcasts, YouTube, and other independent platforms, too many still arrive with the same risk-averse talking points that don’t resonate outside traditional cable news. Pfeiffer argues that authenticity, clarity, and emotionally direct policies, rather than convoluted white papers, are what actually connect with voters. They highlight how Republicans, for all their dishonesty, often come across as unscripted and relatable, something Democrats have yet to replicate at scale.
The conversation broadens to the 2028 landscape, where Gavin Newsom has emerged as one of the few Democrats visibly “fighting” in ways the base recognizes. Pfeiffer pushes back on conspiracy theories about the DNC hand-picking nominees, stressing that the party’s real divide is between those who see Trump as an existential threat and those who treat him as survivable. That split, he argues, explains much of the Democrats’ lack of urgency and cohesion. The two also reflect on Kamala Harris’s 2024 campaign, how internal caution and mixed messaging blunted her early momentum, and why independent media voices like David’s and Pfeiffer’s have a role to play in pushing candidates to engage more authentically with the public.
For more updates from The David Pakman Show, including our daily newsletter, subscribe to our Substack today!
