When Marjorie Taylor Greene starts making some sense

How did we end up here?

Before we get into it: if you’re receiving this via email, thank you. You’re already subscribed. If you’re not, now is the time.

For years, Democrats treated Marjorie Taylor Greene as the perfect caricature of the MAGA movement, the shouting, conspiracy-minded, Q-curious congresswoman from Georgia who seemed to embody every unhinged instinct of the Trump era. Greene wasn’t just a foot soldier in the culture war; she was a mascot for it. The gun-toting memes, the threats to impeach everyone in sight, the bizarre obsession with Jewish space lasers; all of it made her a reliable bogeyman for the left and a kind of performance artist for the right.

So it’s hard to overstate how surreal the last few months have been. Because all of a sudden, Greene is turning her fire on Donald Trump himself.

She has blasted Trump’s bombing of Iran. She helped force a vote to release the Epstein files, a symbolic but politically explosive move that infuriated the Trump White House. And most recently, she has taken to defending Obamacare subsidies. Yes, you read that correctly: Marjorie Taylor Greene, patron saint of the MAGA right, is now warning that ending Affordable Care Act tax credits will cause her own adult children’s premiums to double.

“When the tax credits expire this year,” she wrote, “my own adult children’s insurance premiums for 2026 are going to double, along with all the wonderful families and hard-working people in my district.” She went on to call it “shameful, disgusting, and traitorous” that Republicans were fighting to end these benefits while pretending to be the party of working people.

Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries immediately turned her into a talking point. “Even Marjorie Taylor Greene gets it,” one Democrat quipped on the Senate floor. And rather than retreat, Greene doubled down, appearing on CNN in person to blast her own party’s position on live television. Wolf Blitzer told her she was a “courageous politician and loving mother.” You can almost hear the sound of staffers in the West Wing dropping their coffee mugs.

Cracks in the MAGA Foundation

The larger story here isn’t that Greene has seen the light. It’s that the MAGA coalition is starting to eat itself. The movement that once defined loyalty by blind obedience is beginning to show signs of strain. And Greene, of all people, is the perfect canary in that coal mine.

This week, she went even further, publicly criticizing Trump’s trade policy during an interview with comedian Tim Dillon. In a surprisingly lucid exchange, she accused Trump of enriching “crypto donors” and Silicon Valley types instead of the working-class voters who made him president.

“It shouldn’t be about helping your crypto donors, or your AI donors,” Greene said. “The focus should be the people that stood there for eighteen hours in the cold. I don’t think those people are being served.”

That kind of language, populist, moralistic, vaguely class-based, used to be Trump’s own brand. Now it’s being used against him. Greene’s critique of tariffs and donor favoritism exposes something Republicans rarely admit: Trump’s second term has begun to look less like a populist revolt and more like a kleptocracy with a campaign hat.

To be fair, Greene isn’t exactly a consistent truth-teller. She has been known to pivot on issues when it suits her. But the fact that she is willing to air these grievances publicly tells you something about the internal chaos of the MAGA movement. When even its loudest loyalists start asking where all the “winning” went, the myth of Trump’s infallibility begins to crack.

Why This Matters, Even if She’s No Ally

Let’s get one thing straight: Marjorie Taylor Greene hasn’t become a progressive. She hasn’t renounced her conspiracy theories, her authoritarian streak, or her habit of treating governance like professional wrestling. She is still the same extremist who made a national career out of trolling.

But politics is transactional. And sometimes, strange bedfellows create real openings.

When Greene calls out Trump for corruption, that criticism carries weight precisely because it comes from inside the cult. When she says ordinary working families are being shafted by Republican policies, it forces a conversation Fox News would otherwise ignore. The left doesn’t need to embrace her. It just needs to understand how to use her.

There’s a long history of exploiting fractures within the right. In the 1950s, moderate Republicans quietly leveraged Joe McCarthy’s excesses to discredit the far right. In the 1990s, Democrats weaponized Pat Buchanan’s isolationism to expose the GOP’s internal contradictions on trade and globalization. Greene’s current feud with Trump fits that pattern: a moment when personal ego collides with political reality, and the resulting sparks can be illuminating.

The Populist Paradox

Greene’s rebellion also reveals the deeper paradox of Trumpism. The MAGA movement has always claimed to represent “the forgotten man,” the factory worker, the rural laborer, the middle-American family crushed by elites. But Trump’s policies, from tax cuts to tariffs, have consistently benefited the wealthy while leaving his base struggling.

Now, as Greene herself points out, those same voters are being hit with higher insurance costs, rising consumer prices, and fewer jobs in manufacturing. Her outrage over tariffs isn’t ideological; it’s pragmatic. The people she represents are feeling real economic pain, and Trump’s reflexive protectionism isn’t solving it.

Of course, Greene’s solution isn’t coherent. She’s not proposing a social safety net or labor reform. But by voicing the frustration, she’s puncturing the illusion of MAGA unity. Her complaints sound almost left-wing at times because reality has a way of pulling even the most committed ideologues back toward the center when their constituents start hurting.

Taking Advantage of the Chaos

So what should Democrats and progressives do? Simple: take the gift.

When Greene attacks Trump’s donors, amplify it. When she defends healthcare subsidies, quote her. When she accuses Republicans of betraying working families, agree loudly. Every time she contradicts the party line, she forces conservative media to either defend her or explain why she’s wrong. Either way, it keeps the story alive.

That doesn’t mean turning her into a hero or inviting her to brunch. It means using her as a wedge, a way to highlight the hypocrisy of a movement that claims to fight for “real Americans” while serving billionaires.

Greene’s sudden independence is probably more about survival than principle. She’s watching the ground shift under Trump, and she wants to be positioned for whatever comes next. But intentional or not, she’s doing the left a favor by showing how fragile the MAGA myth really is.

The irony is almost poetic. The same congresswoman who once ranted about globalist cabals is now the one accusing Trump of selling out to crypto billionaires. It’s the kind of political plot twist you couldn’t script.

No, Marjorie Taylor Greene isn’t a progressive. She’s not even a moderate. But for the moment, she’s useful, and that’s enough. Because in politics, loyalty is temporary, power is transactional, and sometimes the best way to fight the monster is to let it start devouring itself.

---

We’re reaching over 100 million people every month across YouTube, podcasts, Substack, and beyond. But algorithms can change. Platforms can fold. And when that happens, this newsletter is how we stay connected.

If you’re not yet a paid subscriber, please consider joining.
If you’re already paid on one platform, consider supporting us on both Substack and our website.

You can subscribe on our website and right here on Substack.

And if you’re really on fire, consider gifting a subscription—we’ve got thousands on our waiting list ready to read, watch, and fight back.

MAGA cancel culture is real—and it’s coming for the press. But they can’t cancel what they don’t control.

Let’s keep building.

—David

PS: Can’t contribute right now? No problem. You can support us for free by subscribing on YouTube, listening to our audio podcast on Spotify or Apple Podcasts, or become a free subscriber to this very Substack. Every bit counts.