The First Amendment Is Being Quietly Dismantled in the Streets

How a constitutional right survives on paper while disappearing in practice

Before we get into it: if you’re receiving this via email, thank you. You’re already subscribed. If you’re not, now is the time.

Anti-ICE protests reveal how a constitutional right can survive on paper while being crushed in practice

Let’s talk about what is really happening right now with the repression of anti-ICE protests, because this may be one of the most important civil liberties stories in the country.

This is no longer an abstract debate about free speech, but rather whether people can safely exercise their most basic rights without gambling their physical safety. And the pattern we are seeing should alarm anyone who cares about the First Amendment, regardless of ideology.

The scenes are increasingly familiar. A handful of people on a sidewalk. Phones out. Someone yelling at an ICE officer, asking what they are doing, demanding a badge number. Often there is no badge number to be seen. Federal agents in tactical gear, faces covered, weapons visible. Unmarked vehicles. Very little communication.

Then something shifts.

Not because anyone attacks an agent. Not because anyone blocks an operation.

But because someone speaks.

First Amendment being turned against Americans

This is the moment we have to confront. The First Amendment has not been repealed. No law has been passed outlawing protest. But the right itself is being turned against the people trying to exercise it.

Last week, we showed video of our friend Jesse Dollemore, who was doing exactly what Americans are supposed to be allowed to do. He was yelling. He was criticizing. He was calling out federal agents for their actions in public. He did not touch anyone. He did not block anyone. He did not threaten anyone.

He used his voice, and he was able to walk away.

Many others have not been so lucky.

Arbitrary enforcement is the point

We have now seen countless videos of people shoved to the ground, dragged across pavement, zip-tied, tackled, and detained. In many cases, these are American citizens who are not even targets of the raids. Their only “crime” is being present, filming, and speaking. Sometimes loudly. Sometimes angrily. But speech nonetheless.

They are not rioting. They are not vandalizing. They are not interfering. They are protesting.

What makes this especially dangerous is how arbitrary it has become. One person can scream directly at an agent and walk away unharmed. Another person stands ten feet back with a phone and gets tackled and dragged down the street. There is no longer a clear standard for what is allowed.

Everything depends on the mood, panic, or interpretation of the agent on the scene.

The new catch-all justification is “impeding our operation.” Standing on a sidewalk with a phone becomes the modern version of “resisting arrest.” Yelling becomes interference and filming becomes a threat.

That should terrify anyone who believes rights are supposed to be durable. Rights do not survive based on vibes. They do not survive based on whether an armed officer feels annoyed, rushed, or disrespected.

What ICE is engaged in right now is not simply enforcement. It is intimidation. It is the deliberate transformation of speech into something dangerous.

Fear is doing the suppression work

And here is the part that matters most: it is working.

People are choosing not to protest. Not because they do not care. Not because they agree with what ICE is doing. But because they do not want their face smashed into concrete for yelling. They do not want a pepper ball to the head. They do not want to risk blindness from so-called less-lethal rounds. They do not want to explain to their kids why they were arrested for holding a phone and cannot pick them up from daycare.

That reaction is not cowardice. It is rational.

People are being asked to risk bodily harm to exercise a right that is supposed to be safe by definition. A constitutional right should not require a physical gamble.

This is exactly how a right dies in practice. Nobody repeals it. Nobody formally bans it. Instead, the consequences become violent, unpredictable, and arbitrary enough that fear does the work on its own. Participation drops while silence spreads.

The incompetence of it all

There is another layer that makes this even more dangerous. Incompetence.

Many of these encounters are being handled by agents with minimal training, people who have no business managing crowds, dissent, or protected speech. Yelling is treated as obstruction. Cameras are treated like weapons. Mere presence is framed as interference.

That is how you end up watching footage where nothing illegal is happening, and suddenly someone is thrown to the ground. Every second feels like it could explode, because it can.

When agents are this jumpy, this opaque, and this insulated from accountability, everyone is at risk. Protesters. Bystanders. Journalists. People doing nothing more than watching.

The cost of speech is no longer just arrest, which would already be unacceptable. It is bodily harm, up to and including death. Too loud, you might get tackled. Too angry, you might get beaten. Say the wrong thing, and you might get dragged.

So when people ask why more Americans are not in the streets, this is the answer. People see what happens.

We need more protest, not less. But at the individual level, the First Amendment is being suppressed through randomness. You show up, and maybe nothing happens. Or maybe you are injured. Or arrested. Or worse.

A right only exists if you do not have to gamble your life to exercise it. When speech is treated as a physical threat, that logic does not stay confined to immigration protests. Today it is ICE. Tomorrow it is labor protests, climate protests, anti-war demonstrations, journalists, cop watchers, or anyone deemed inconvenient.

We are heading down a dangerous path. Not just because people are being hurt, although they are. But because the message is clear.

Speak if you want. Just understand what it might cost you.

And once people decide that cost is too high, the silence does the rest.

---

We’re reaching over 150 million people every month across YouTube, podcasts, Substack, and beyond. But algorithms can change. Platforms can fold. And when that happens, this newsletter is how we stay connected.

If you’re not yet a paid subscriber, please consider joining.
If you’re already paid on one platform, consider supporting us on both Substack and our website.

You can subscribe on our website and right here on Substack.

And if you’re really on fire, consider gifting a subscription—we’ve got thousands on our waiting list ready to read, watch, and fight back.

Let’s keep building.

—David

PS: Can’t contribute right now? No problem. You can support us for free by subscribing on YouTube, listening to our audio podcast on Spotify or Apple Podcasts, or become a free subscriber to this very Substack. Every bit counts.